Monday, September 08, 2014

"STANDING IN LINE AT THE HUNTSVILLE FREE CLINIC IN ALABAMA"

Arab, Alabama

Well, it is theoretical Monday at Scission and what I will be posting is kind of theoretical, kind of historical, kind of just talking, just kind of...

Let's see, how can I describe this more fully.  It is about the deep South, but more than that.  It is about globalization, but less then that.   It is about slavery and chain gangs and all that. It is about the day to day experience of the poor, of the multitude, for sure.  It is about populism and "Big Jim" Folsom and a little George Wallace, too.  It's about pain pills and pain, factories and not. It is about a world gone by, a world still here, and a world to come. It speaks to religion and to Huntsville, Alabama (where a close friend's father was once the commanding general at the Red Stone Arsenal.  The General was  an interesting and kind man, who I came to know personally.  He  even  once wrote a letter, on my behalf, to the judge at my sentencing hearing following my conviction in a bombing conspiracy case.  I thought it was a rather amazing act, by a man who certainly did not have to do such a thing.  It perplexed the judge to no end.  That would make a good story itself). 

Anyway, the post below is an interesting read and a telling one...if you just think about it for a bit.  It comes from the journal Insurgent Notes.


NOTES ON ALABAMA: SEARCHING FOR THE GHOST OF "BIG JIM" FOLSOM

by Curtis Price


Standing in line at the Huntsville Free Clinic in Alabama. A provider of last resort, the Free Clinic serves the poor and working class of Huntsville not covered by Alabama’s stingy Medicaid program. Many users of Free Clinic services work, but at jobs that don’t offer health insurance. Volunteer-run, the Free Clinic becomes the only lifeline many in this situation will have to any type of health care.
Today is one of two weekly prescription refill days. The Free Clinic contacts the free supply programs offered by drug companies to cover prescriptions for people unable to pay. This service, dubbed “compassionate access,” is not done out of either compassion or genuine access, but granted to ward off any demands for expanded state run prescription programs or price caps on soaring drug prices.
“You always can get a job you don’t want and never a job you do.”
—Overheard in Free Clinic waiting line
I’m eavesdropping on the conversation in front of me, three middle-aged men, two white and one black. They are the face of the new hidden unemployment, the disposable middle-aged men laid off or injured from jobs who can’t collect Social Security yet but who can’t get hired either. Many are unemployable because of the epidemic of diabetes, high blood pressure and other chronic diseases that especially ravages the Deep South. No jobs at the local auto plants or the booming high-tech defense-related industries that still thrive in Huntsville. Men like these survive off wives’ and girlfriends’ income from low-waged service-sector jobs at Walmart, at the fast food restaurants and dollar stores that fill working-class Huntsville strip malls along with pawn shops, Good Wills, and title and payday-loan storefronts.
The payday and auto-title loans are two modern forms of debt updating and continuing the South’s sharecropping and debt-peonage legacy. It works like this. You are hard up for cash. You borrow against your next paycheck or put your automobile title up as collateral at interest rates up to 400 percent yearly. If you don’t repay right away (and many people already teetering near the economic edge can’t), you become snared into further cycles of inescapable debt.[1] The practice is perfectly legal and indeed some of the biggest banks in the country, such as Wells Fargo Bank, participate in this predatory lending, although more and more legislation is getting introduced to curb its worst excesses.[2]
The void—economic and otherwise—of superfluous men like this is filled by pills: Oxycontins, Lorcets, Darvocets and other prescription painkillers. Getting a steady source of prescription pain medicine becomes not only a personal way to dull the pain but an economic hustle too. Pills can be resold and thus generate pocket money. So not surprisingly talk in the waiting line turns to the latest news about what doctors “kick out” prescriptions with few questions asked.
One doctor, banned from Alabama, now practices a few miles up the road in southern Tennessee. Speaking about his exile from Alabama, one man asks incredulously, “What do they expect the man to do? Go work at McDonalds?” The others laugh at the absurdity of the thought, although none of them can get jobs at McDonalds either.
“Connecting Others to Christ One At A Time”
—One of several similar T-shirts worn inside the clinic waiting room
The more time I spend in the Deep South, the better I understand the role religion plays. Religion is not the opium of the masses or the sigh of the oppressed; religion is now, in the absence of any collective organization, their insurance policy.
Thus, in the face of hardships, God oversees and personally guides the faithful through all life’s ups and downs. In contrast to the role the black church played in the South during the Civil Rights era, today’s churches, both black and white, now reflect the individualization and fragmentation of American life, where there is no one to help you outside your immediate family and friends—assuming they aren’t drowning in their own messy, complicated personal problems. The deep roots of Southern religion remain, but its underlying social causes and thus social functions have changed.
Two women, one black and one white, part-time school bus drivers, probably not eligible for healthcare benefits and so forced to use the Free Clinic, talk across the small drab waiting room. The white driver tells of her mother’s slow death from cancer and how her mother was “tired of living, worn out by life” before she died. She then talks loudly about how God oversees her every move, personally managing her life, keeping her on the right path.
Murmurs of assent wash across the room. In some ways, this woman’s testimony is both very moving—and very egotistical. This current view of God has nothing to do with social justice or a better world in some vague way, but instead reflects how isolated and struggling so many of the working poor’s lives have become in the United States today. It looks up to the heavens for what can’t be found anywhere on earth.
This is a part of the country that the United States left, in the traditional sense, walked away from decades ago, preferring to impose change through the courts and government decree, and to withdraw into the fractured movements of identity. But Alabama, like much of the Deep South, has a rich history of class struggle. In the 1930s, the mines and steel factories surrounding Birmingham, now shut or just a shadow of their former strength, were in a virtual state of civil war, struggles more often than not shipwrecked on the reefs of race.
During the Red Scare 1950s, Alabama was run by a populist governor, “Big Jim” Folsom, a colorful, 6’6″, hard-drinking, womanizing, larger-than-life figure who openly preached interracial unity of the “branchheads” (the poor farmers and working class) against the “Big Mules,” the handful of Alabama’s land owners controlling the state (3).[3]
Folsom’s campaign rallies opened with him intentionally greeting and shaking the hands of black attendees in a symbolic but potent signal that blacks were welcome. Folsom famously demonstrated his disdain for the trappings of power by having himself photographed smoking a cigar, with shoeless feet propped up on the executive desk of the governor’s mansion.
Even an arch-reactionary and racist like George Wallace, who got his political baptism in Folsom’s campaigns before veering to the right, was denounced by the Republican Party when he ran for President in the late 1960s, as a “country and western Marxist” for increasing state spending and ownership and raising public sector worker salaries. After unleashing the demons of racism all his political life, Wallace, according to historian Dan T. Carter, at the end of his last term as governor, by then incapacitated in a wheelchair from a failed assassination attempt, openly worried, “I hope the rich and powerful don’t take over now.”[4] This strain of populism, sails unfurled and powered with the largesse of New Deal winds, a populism contradictory, frequently nakedly corrupt and never ultimately threatening the interests of the big money men, is dead in the Deep South today.
One of the many dirty secrets of American history is that New Deal projects, along with nearly every other of the public works construction widely credited with modernizing Southern infrastructure and launching the New South, were worked by un-free labor.[5] Whenever a local construction crew or farmer needed manpower, the sheriff would arrest blacks and poor whites on minor charges, with willing judges sentencing the convicted to work-gangs building roads and harvesting crops.
If slavery was the first wave of one major source of primitive accumulation of capital in the United States, the post-slavery period until WWII became the second, as former slave-owners, deprived of their biggest form of capital—the institution of chattel slavery—scrambled to reconstitute their wealth through a second wave of un-free labor, assisted by the state and the judicial system.
As Haywood Patterson, one of the Scottsboro Boys, described this system in his remarkable autobiography:
The prison farms of Alabama, there are a half-dozen going all the time, that is the business the state of Alabama is in. Many a guy on these prison road camps, he was there because some Alabama county put up a sign during harvest time. The sign said that vagrants without money must work on a prison farm or road for thirty or sixty days. These guys they arrested and stamped a crime on the fact they were broke, and puts them to working.
Besides what the state did through its prisons and farms, our rackets inside the prison were small. The prison farms of Alabama, that is the part of the old slavery that still stands down there. Today, like in the olden days, they feed a man enough to keep him alive and work him all day. Long time ago, old master, he got the take from that. Today the state of Alabama, it gets the take direct, through its prisons and the officials who run them.[6]
Even as late as the 1990s, people here tell me, prison chain gangs could be found working in the heat of the summer sun on highways in Bullock County, outside Montgomery. By that time, however, the effect was mostly symbolic: the resurrection of the chain gangs was a sign of being tough on crime and not as a form of economic exploitation. But in the South, symbolism becomes a potent carrier of past history, which is why skirmishes over removing Confederate era generals names from schools becomes one of the low-level signs of struggle here.
***
Triana, AL
From the late 1940s until the 1970s, the Olin Corporation, contracted by the Army on nearby Redstone Arsenal to manufacture DDT, dumped an estimated 4,000 tons of DDT into the springs feeding into the Tennessee River. The locals in this small, all-black town fished the river to supplement their diets. In the late 1970s, the Tennessee Valley Authority documented hazardous levels of DDT in the river surrounding Triana. The report was ignored. That is, until the then-mayor of Triana, concerned, asked the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) to come and test Triana residents. The CDC found high levels of DDT in Triana residents’ blood. One elderly Triana man had the highest level of DDT ever recorded in the bloodstream of a living person. The subsequent disaster was so severe that Triana was dubbed the most unhealthy town in America and a “Southern Love Canal,” after the well-known 1970s environmental catastrophe in upstate New York.
In the court battles that followed, Triana’s mayor, in a decision still cited in environmental law classes, very shrewdly negotiated not only individual cash settlements (my friend in Alabama had several relatives who got them), but also won lifelong healthcare though a specially set up health clinic. It was a brilliant move that ensured people who would never get decent healthcare got it. Triana in this way became the only Southern town with guaranteed healthcare for all citizens, a rarity even outside the South.
But DDT at the time was a poorly studied poison with little-known long-term effects in humans. Only later did research discover DDT exposure was linked to heart attacks and other chronic medical conditions. So even the clinic couldn’t prevent waves of early death and disability among Triana residents, but in a losing battle just retroactively treat the illnesses. My friend’s mother’s early death in her late 40s from a heart attack he suspects was from DDT.
Triana was technically considered cleaned up after a massive infusion of Environmental Protection Agency money from the federal government—and promptly forgotten about. When I visited Triana, while muffled booming from weapon detonation in the sprawling Redstone Arsenal next door echoed in the air, I saw people fishing from the banks of the Tennessee, even though researchers have detected high levels of new carcinogens again in river waters.[7]
***
Did you know that Whitney Houston was secretly drowned in her hotel bathtub while members of the Hollywood Illuminati gathered in a ballroom below to steal her soul? A sign of the depths of defeat in the black working class can be seen in the widespread belief in the Illuminati. The Illuminati, a covert order of the rich and powerful who secretly manipulate and control everything from behind the scenes, once the province of white conspiracy theory, is now credited with nearly everything wrong in the world.
Though not just confined to Southern black working-class milieus, it was there that I heard the Illuminati referred to offhandedly as a fact of everyday life the most—“Oh, the Illuminati must have been behind it.”
Along with this fatalistic belief in secret control being exercised over one’s life, a control so complete that is futile to do anything about it, goes hand in hand, paradoxically, with a blind faith in Barack Obama that’s difficult to challenge. Obama becomes a mythical superhero always ready to deliver like a fantastic savior from above but forever foiled by the evil machinations of the Illuminati.
Obama gets credited with creating millions of new jobs and saving the country single-handedly from economic collapse. The plain black cell phones now available free to low-income people on social services in Alabama are widely known as “Obamaphones” because it’s assumed Obama personally ordered them given out to the poor, even though the phones are a result of a class action settlement against the major phone companies that predates the Obama presidency. An Alabama friend credits the disappearance of an old attempted murder charge from his court records as a result of Obama ordering Attorney General Eric Holder to wipe out false charges filed against black men in the South.
In this respect the fatalism of belief in the Illuminati coupled with blind faith in waiting for Obama to “deliver the goods,” although never complete, all work in the end to demobilize opposition or questioning.
***
But winds of change are now blowing through the South. Globalization—and make no mistake, the South is thoroughly caught up in the social and economic changes going along with it—has brought new fault lines—and new possibilities. In Alabama, formerly lily-white mountain towns outside Huntsvile such as Arab and Athens now draw growing Latino populations, and tiny Gunterville, population 3,000, hosts an influx of Haitian refugees who have set up shops on the main street. Whole industries such as poultry are now largely Latino worked. It is no accident, faced with this rising, visible tide of immigration—a 280 percent increase from 1990 to 2000—that Alabama passed some of the most repressive anti-immigration laws in the United States.
After decades of out-migration, the South is undergoing reverse in-migration, especially among blacks forsaking the violence and disarray of Northern inner cities for what many see as a slower-paced, family-friendly South. Foreign auto transplants such as Mercedes-Benz, Volkswagen and Nissan are relocating below the Mason-Dixon Line. Like the mechanization of agriculture and World War II, these developments signify, as Newsweek reporter William Emerson put it in describing earlier effects of school desegregation, “slow, mighty shifts in the sub-soils of custom, tradition and way of life.”[8]
Huntsville itself, for example, once a sleepy textile town where part of the Scottsboro Boys trial took place in the 1930s, is now a major center of aerospace and high-tech research and development. As the South steadily transforms, so hand in hand will its potential importance grow in US social and economic developments. This process of course is wildly uneven, with at least in the short term counter-trends likely flaring as well, but the South’s long legacy in US history as a socially backward, economically underdeveloped “other” semi-colony not quite part of the country, finally seems destined to end.
  1. [1] Institute for Southern Studies, “Payday Lenders Target Black and Latino Communities.” ↩
  2. [2] “Regulators to Restrict Big Banks’ Predatory Lending,” New York Times (2013). ↩
  3. [3] Two excellent studies of Folsom have so far been written, Big Mules & Branchheads: James E. Folsom and Political Power in Alabama by Carl Grafton and Anne Permaloff, and, more biographical, The Little Man’s Big Friend: James E. Folsom in Alabama Politics, 1946–1958, by George E. Simms. ↩
  4. [4] Dan T. Carter, The Politics of Rage: George Wallace, the Origins of the New Conservatism, and the Transformation of American Politics (1995), p. 463. By then, Wallace had renounced his racist past and, remarkably, won 30 percent of the black vote in his last race for Alabama governor. ↩
  5. [5] This hidden history was unearthed in historian Douglas A. Blackmon’s 2008 bestseller, Slavery by Another Name: The Re-Enslavement of Black Americans from the Civil War to World War II. ↩
  6. [6] Scottsboro Boy, p. 114. The Scottsboro Boys, nine black youth framed for the alleged rape of two white women that later turned out false, became an international cause célèbre in the 1930s. While most of the defendants, with the notable exception of Haywood Patterson, were eventually released after years in jail, nearly all, in the little known aftermath, led tragically abbreviated lives. Patterson escaped from an Alabama prison to Michigan, where the governor refused to extradite him. However Patterson knifed a man to death in a barroom brawl in Detroit and returned to prison a few years later, where he died of cancer at age 36, having spent most of adult life incarcerated. ↩
  7. [7] Triana Justice Page. ↩
  8. [8] Quoted in Jason Sokol, There Goes My Everything: White Southerners in the Age of Civil Rights, 1945–1975 (2006), p. 115. ↩

Friday, September 05, 2014

THE REAL CRIME IS THE MASS CRIMINALIZATION OF COMMUNITIES OF COLOR



For Jails and Cops friday at Scission, let's try something different.  Let's try a video that you should see, use, and spread around.  This is a video produced by the Black Alliance for Just Immigration (BAJI).  This video is only four minutes long but it clearly defines mass incarceration, mass criminalization, and the racist immigration detention and deportation agenda in this country.   As Stop Detaining Immigrants writes:


In a day and age where divide and conquer is the norm, and the folks aim to pit citizens against non-citizens, African Americans against migrants, and those with a criminal record against those without, it’s our duty to stand in unity against those who ultimately aim to keep our communities under-resourced and oppressed.

We know that we truly are stronger together, so please help us share the video and build beyond #TheRealCrime!

BAJI defines itself as:


...an education and advocacy group comprised of African Americans and black immigrants from Africa, Latin American and the Caribbean. It was founded in April 2006 in response to the massive outpouring of opposition of immigrants and their supporters to the repressive immigration bills then under consideration by the U.S. Congress.

Black activists in the Oakland/San Francisco Bay Area were called to action by Rev. Kelvin Sauls,a South African immigrant and Rev. Phillip Lawson, a long time Civil Rights leader and co-founder/co-chair of the California Interfaith Coalition for Immigrant Rights.

BAJI also grew out of the efforts of the Priority Africa Network. PAN organizes Africa Diaspora Dialogues which have brought African Americans and black immigrants from Africa, the Caribbean and Latin America together to dialogue about the myths and stereotypes as well as the cultural, social and political issues that divide our communities.

BAJI provides the African American community with a progressive analysis and framework on immigration that links the interests of African Americans with those of immigrants of color. BAJI’s analysis emphasizes the impact of racism and economic globalization on African American and immigrant communities as a basis for forging alliances across these communities.

Our VisionRacial, social, and economic justice for all.

Principles of  Unity

  • All people, regardless of immigration status, country of origin, race, color, creed, gender, sexual orientation or HIV status deserve human rights as well as social and economic justice.
  • Historically and currently, U.S. immigration policy has been infused with racism, enforcing unequal and punitive standards for immigrants of color.
  • Immigration to the United States is driven by an unjust international economic system that deprives people of the ability to earn a living and raise their families in their home countries. Through international trade, lending, aid and investment policies, the United States government and corporations are the main promoters and beneficiaries of this unjust economic system.
  • African Americans, with our history of being economically exploited, marginalized and discriminated against, have much in common with people of color who migrate to the United States, documented and undocumented.
Values Statement: BAJI values the kinship of our humanity by embracing gender equality, diversity of generations, immigration status and experience.

Again, spend a few minutes, check out the video, and then pass it along.

The following is from BAJI.


THE REAL CRIME: MASS CRIMINALIZATION OF OUR COMMUNITIES


Subscribe to Download Our New Paper

“Understanding Mass Incarceration & Migrant Detention”
Screen Shot 2014-06-24 at 3.55.41 PM

#TheRealCrime

Everyday, people of color in the United States are being criminalized for their economic condition, their race, their migrant status, gender and so much more. There is a pandemic of mass criminalization that is ravaging our neighborhoods and our society. Structural racism and oppression would have us believe that we are inherently flawed, that we are criminals. However, the real crime is demonizing, criminalizing and imprisoning millions of young men and women, relegating them to the margins of society as disenfranchised, unemployable pariahs. African Americans and other communities of color, including immigrants are being profiled, surveilled, locked up and locked out of society. 
Watch the video to learn more about how this is happening and what we can do to stop the real crime in our communities.

WE WANT TO HEAR FROM YOU – 

1) Will you join us in sharing what you think #therealcrime is on social media?

2) What are your solutions to #therealcrime?


Thursday, September 04, 2014

CANADA'S SHAME: MISSING AND MURDERED INDIGENOUS WOMEN

People attend a vigil for Tina Fontaine and Faron Hall in Winnipeg, Manitoba


The murders and disappearances have gone on since 1980.  One thousand, two hundred murdered or missing.  Must be a huge uproar.  Well, not so much.  

The 1,200 missing or murdered people are aboriginal women and girls in Canada, and when relatives, friends and others go to Ottawa for help, they get not much of anything.

As Warren Kinsella writes at First Perspective, 


Now, we don't even have to say out loud that if the 1,200 murdered or missing were, say, debutantes or Rotarians or hockey players, nobody would be looking for something else to read in today's paper. If it had been a bunch of white girls who had been killed or disappeared, there would be no collective societal shrug taking place.

Holy God Almighty, there'd be a hue and a cry like none this nation had ever seen. You'd have mild-mannered suburbanites storming Parliament Hill with pitchforks and torches if we were talking about 20 Midget "A" teams, or the entire population of Tilt Cove, Newfoundland, or Greenwood, B.C.

But it's aboriginal women. And so nobody's enraged and nobody's storming Parliament Hill.



Some of you may say, well, people get killed and go missing all the time.  Uh huh, well not like this.  As Indigenous Nationhood points out:


Indigenous women suffer a victimization rate three times higher than the Canadian population and are grossly over-represented in the number of women that go murdered and missing. While homicides have declined for Canadian women, the same cannot be said for Indigenous women. Indigenous women make up 4% of the population in Canada but 11% of the missing women and 16% of the murdered women. While these numbers are high, the levels in the western provinces and northern territories are frightening. The number of murdered Indigenous women in Manitoba is 49% and in Saskatchewan its 55%.

Well, surely you say, the RCMP, the other police authorities, the courts are doing all they can.  Uh huh, well, not so much.  Again from Indigenous Nationhood:

 The most disturbing of all reports is the 2013 report entitled Those Who Take Us Away: Abusive Policing and Failures in Protection of Indigenous Women and Girls in Northern British Colombia prepared by Human Rights Watch. This report concluded that Indigenous women and girls are not only “under-protected” by the RCMP but are in fact the objects of RCMP abuse. They highlighted the many allegations of RCMP officers sexually exploiting and abusing young Indigenous girls.. There are reports of confinement, rape, and sexual assault on Indigenous girls and some have led to law suits. They also reported on a class action law suit against the RCMP by its own female officers for sexual harassment and gender discrimination...

...While the government and RCMP have, at times, tried to blame the victims for their own circumstances, it seems very clear that a large part of the problem is government and RCMP’s racist and sexist attitudes towards Indigenous women and girls. In addition to Canada’s discriminatory laws and policies against Indigenous peoples generally, and women specifically, the Human Rights Watch group even reports on an example of the judiciary being involved in the abuse against these girls. David Ramsay, a provincial court judge, was accused of sexually assaulting and violently abusing girls between 12 and 17 and eventually plead guilty. How are Indigenous women and girls supposed to get justice if the Justice system participates in the abuse and rape of these women?

 One of the biggest impediments to moving forward is the continued failure of the federal government to have the RCMP investigated to determine the full extent to which racism against Indigenous people and sexism against women in general hamper their work. Harper’s own discriminatory attitude towards Indigenous peoples is a significant barrier to moving forward. Even the most recent United Nations report from the Rapporteur commented on how poor the relationship is between Canada and Indigenous peoples and has become worse since the last visit to Canada in 2003. The United Nations is not alone in its observation of deteriorating government relations – the Bertelsmann Foundation is the latest to note that Canada’s record on governance has declined under Harper, especially when it comes to Indigenous peoples. The UN further stated that Canada’s negative public comments about Indigenous peoples risks social peace. 

There are indigenous people, even some others, who do care and they are fighting for recognition, fighting to ensure something is done, fighting for the missing and dead.  For example, I take you to Manitoba where  the death of a 15-year-old girl, Tina Fontaine, has prompted dozens of people to camp in the shadow of the Manitoba Legislature for days, calling for an inquiry into missing and murdered aboriginal women.  The camp was set up two weeks ago  following the discovery of Tina’s body wrapped in a bag in the Red River. The number of tents has continued to grow, as has the resolve and optimism of many protesters who hope this tragedy can be a turning point.  Kylo Prince, speaking for many at the camp, says what is happening is merely a continuation of the genocide of Canada's native people. He says there s always hope.



“If I had no hope, I wouldn’t be standing here. I would be sitting in an alley, slamming some whisky with a needle in my arm and a crack pipe hanging out of my lips. But no, there is hope. We will conquer the darkness, but with light. We can’t fight it with anger or hatred.”

He thinks that maybe the fact that the Conservative federal government has reversed itself and now said it is will to participate in a roundtable discussion about the missing and the killed aboriginal women is one of those hopeful signs.



I don't know.

The government's overall response to Tina's death is nothing to write home about.  The government is thinking a national DNA database would be good  and maybe some sort of aboriginal justice initiatives (aimed at aboriginal offenders).  Sara Hunt is a member of the Kwagiulth band of the Kwakwaka’wakw First Nation. She is an independent writer, researcher and advocate who has worked for more than 15 years on Indigenous anti-violence and justice initiatives.  She has something to say about this and more:



 I would argue that these efforts serve to distract from root causes by focusing on indigenous people themselves as the problem.

This sentiment was reinforced when Winnipeg police Sgt. John O’Donovan stated that Tina didn’t realize “the danger she was putting herself in.” What danger is this? The danger of living in a society that condones violence against indigenous women, where killers face few deterrents, and where missing women are blamed for putting themselves “at risk.”
Surely tracking indigenous girls’ DNA so they can be identified after they die is not the starting point for justice. Indigenous women want to matter before we go missing. We want our lives to matter as much as our deaths; our stake in the present political struggle for indigenous resurgence is as vital as the future.

So do we need an inquiry?

We need to stop the killing of 15-year-old native girls. We need to put an end to the abduction of indigenous women. We need to overhaul a justice system in which justice is so distorted that it is no longer recognizable. We need no more excuses, no more condolences, no more lists of missing women. We need an end to treating violence as mundane.

An inquiry will only help if it has action attached and if it shifts power into the hands of indigenous women, meaning it is led by indigenous women. Such a process will only be meaningful if it has the scope and power to illuminate the multi-layered systemic failures which contribute to this relentless violence. Working across jurisdictional divisions and levels of governmental responsibility in the child welfare system, the justice system, the education system and the systems of transportation and housing, we need to find some semblance of accountability toward indigenous girls and women.

Accountability means supporting existing anti-violence measures already being initiated by indigenous communities. These include rite-of-passage ceremonies to restore honour for young women, the Moosehide Campaign in which native boys and men take on culturally-relevant responsibilities to end violence toward women, and mentoring between girls and women which fosters the resurgence of women’s cultural roles at a local level. Organizations such as the Native Youth Sexual Health Network must also be supported in their powerful educational work by and for native youth. Accountability means supporting indigenous visions of justice, restoring our humanity and upholding girls’ resistance and leadership.

Treating our deaths as unremarkable is a form of violence that needs to stop along with the murders themselves. Taking steps to end the violence now is the only route to justice.



I have been covering this story for years and it seems to just never change.  Well, here is just an example of one of the reasons why....from  Intercontinental Cry.


HARPER SOLICITS RESEARCH TO BLAME FIRST NATIONS FOR MURDERED, MISSING AND TRADED INDIGENOUS WOMEN


Canada’s shameful colonial history as it relates to Indigenous peoples and women specifically is not well known by the public at large. The most horrific of Canada’s abuses against Indigenous peoples are not taught in schools. Even public discussion around issues like genocide have been censored by successive federal governments, and most notably by Harper’s Conservatives. Recently, the new Canadian Museum for Human Rights refused to use the term “genocide” to describe Canada’s laws, policies and actions towards Indigenous peoples which led to millions of deaths. The reason?: because that term was not acceptable to the federal government and the museum is after all, a Crown corporation.
Aside from the fact that this museum will be used as a propaganda tool for Canada vis-à-vis the international community, Harper’s Conservatives are also paying for targeted research to back up their propaganda as it relates to murdered, missing and traded Indigenous women. This is not the first time that Harper has paid for counter information and propaganda material as it relates to Indigenous peoples, and it likely won’t be the last. However, this instance of soliciting targeted research to help the government blame Indigenous peoples for their own victimization and oppression is particularly reprehensible given the massive loss of life involved over time.
The issue of murdered and missing Indigenous women was made very public by the Native Women’s Association of Canada (NWAC) several years ago through their dedicated research, community engagement and advocacy efforts. Even the United Nations took notice and starting commenting on Canada’s obligation to address this serious issue. Yet, in typical Harper-Conservative style, once the issue became a hot topic in the media, they cut critical funding to NWAC’s Sisters in Spirit program which was the heart of their research and advocacy into murdered and missing Indigenous women.
To further complicate the matter, any attempts for a national inquiry into the issue has been thwarted by the federal government, despite support for such an inquiry by the provinces and territories. One need only look at the fiasco of the Pickton Inquiry in British Columbia to understand how little governments in Canada value the lives of Indigenous women, their families and communities. The inquiry was headed by Wally Oppal, the same man who previously denied the claims of Indigenous women who were forcibly sterilized against their knowledge and consent. The inquiry seemed more interested in insulating the RCMP from investigation and prosecution than it was about hearing the stories of Indigenous women.
Now, the Canadian public has to deal with a new chapter to this story – the sale of Indigenous women into the sex trades. The CBC recently reported that current research shows that Indigenous women, girls and babies in Canada were taken onto US ships to be sold into the sex trade. While this is not new information for Indigenous peoples, it is something that Canada has refused to recognize in the past. The research also shows that Indigenous women are brought onto these boats never to be seen from again.
The issue of murdered and missing Indigenous women has now expanded to murdered, missing and traded women. One might have expected a reaction from both the Canadian government and the Assembly of First Nations (AFN). Yet, the day after the story hit the news, the AFN was tweeting about local competitions and the federal government was essentially silent. I say essentially, because while all of this was taking place, the federal government put together a Request for Proposals on MERX (#275751) to solicit research to blame the families and communities of Indigenous women for being sold into the sex trade.
Instead of making a call for true academic research into the actual causes and conditions around Indigenous women, girls and babies being sold into the sex trade, the federal government solicited research to prove:
(1) the involvement of family members in their victimization;
(2) the level to which domestic violence is linked to the sale of Indigenous women into the sex trade; and
(3) even where they are investigating gang involvement, it is within the context of family involvement of the trade of Indigenous women.
The parameters of the research excludes looking into federal and/or provincial laws and policies towards Indigenous peoples; funding mechanisms which prejudice them and maintain them in the very poverty the research identifies; and negative societal attitudes formed due to government positions vis-à-vis Indigenous women like:
  • rapes and abuse in residential schools;
  • forced sterilizations;
  • the theft of thousands of Indigenous children into foster care;
  • the over-representation of Indigenous women in jails;
  • and the many generations of Indigenous women losing their Indian status and membership and being kicked off reserves by federal law.
The research also leaves out a critical aspect of this research which is federal and provincial enforcement laws, policies and actions or lack thereof in regards to the reports of murdered, missing and traded Indigenous women, girls and babies. The epic failure of police to follow up on reports and do proper investigations related to these issues have led some experts to conclude that this could have prevented and addressed murdered, missing and traded Indigenous women. Of even greater concern are the allegations that have surfaced in the media in relation to RCMP members sexually assaulting Indigenous women and girls.
This MERX Request for Proposals is offensive and should be retracted and re-issued in a more academically-sound manner which looks to get at the full truth, versus a federally-approved pre-determined outcome.
It’s time Canada opened up the books, and shed light on the real atrocities in this country so that we can all move forward and address them.
Originally published at Indigenous Nationhood

Wednesday, September 03, 2014

FIGHT ISIS, ARM THE PKK NOW

PKK FIGHTERS

I have seen my share of evil in the world, but not much that I can think of approaches the evil known as ISIS or The Islamic State.  These people are more than fascists, more than nazis, more than extreme theocratic fundamentalist medieval bastards.  These people are psychotic.  What is the most amazing thing someways to me is their ability to attract vicious killers from all over the world to what they call a cause?

This is not cause.


This is brutality run amuck.


This is absolute power corrupting absolutely.


These guys make Hitler and Pol Pot look good.


These jackals make Rwanda look like a birthday party.


These pigs make George Bush look like just a good ole boy.


Before you come back and tell me how the USA is responsible for them, let me say, I get that. Washington’s brutal interventions wrecked Iraq and created the present crisis. However, that was then and this is now.  


As is so often the case at times like these the world stands by wringing its hands, mouthing off, dropping a bomb here or there, but doing nothing all that much.  Wasn't that the case with Hitler, Pol Pot, and George Armstrong Custer?  Didn't the world stand by during the genocide in Armenia and Rwanda?  Hasn't most everyone looked the other way for the last five hundred plus years while the indigenous population in North America was the victim of genocide, too?


What is the freaking deal?


So what to do?


Well, here is a thought.  How about arming the Kurds?  I mean really arming the Kurds.  They seem to be the one group of human beings willing, ready, and eager to confront ISIS face to face.  Hell, they're doing it.  It is clear that delivering weapons to the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) would strike a blow at ISIS.  Kurdistan Communities Union (KCK) Executive committee co-President Cemil Bayık  said recently that resisting ISIS and helping in cooperating against it was a humanitarian duty.  He is absolutely correct.  DIHA writes:



Bayık went on to add that if Germany was considering arming the Kurds it needs to consider the effectiveness of the PKK in stopping ISIS. 

'It was the PKK who most deserved armed support'


Bayık made it clear that while they were not against the arming of South Kurdistan by the USA, Germany and other European States that they were in a position to say it was the PKK who most deserved such support. To arm the PKK would be a blow to ISIS, Bayık said. It would also mean protecting Kurds, Christians, Turkmen and all other faith and cultural groups. “For this reason” he concluded “we see it as the responsibility of the USA and European States, above all Germany, to aid the PKK and are people who are resisting with weapons without delay.”

The PKK reportedly has currently  approximately 20,000 fighters in Syria with up to another 40,000 fighting the Islamic State in Iraq and Turkey.  One of those fighters Kawar Singali, is quoted at Systemic Capital:



The Iraqi army collapsed and the Peshmerga failed. We are the only force who has repeatedly defeated jihadist. They fear us, and although no one is helping us, we are getting bigger and more experienced.

Fighting to date without heavy weaponry, forced to buy their arms on the black market, the PKK have utilized guerrilla tactics to show some serious capabilities in defeating ISIS. 


The PKK Syrian units, for example, got through Islamic States lines to assist tens of thousands of Yazidis escape from Mount Sinjar where the Christian based groups escaped as the IS (Islamic State) overran their homes in Mosul. The Yazidis were threatened with extermination by the IS, which regards them as “devil worshippers”.  Although many thousands perished and thousands of women were kidnapped, an escape corridor was established through which 200,000 refugees were evacuated to Rojava. Since then they have worked to train Yazhidi youth, male and female, to fight with them.  Other Kurdish forces from the Federal Kurdistan Region have also been fighting ISIS with some success.  However, as McClatchy News reported three weeks ago those forces were stalled until the arrival of the PKK forces:



Visits to frontline positions...made it clear that an influx of fighters with links to the Kurdish Workers Party, known by its Kurdish initials PKK, had played a major role in driving the Islamic State from key areas within a 30-minute drive of Erbil, the capital of Iraq’s Kurdistan Regional Government. It was Erbil’s possible fall last week that ended weeks of Obama administration inaction on Iraq.


“The PKK took Makhmour” a peshmerga fighter at a checkpoint outside Makhmour acknowledged, shaking his head in admiration. Then, using the Arabic acronym for the Islamic State, he offered an explanation: “They’re very experienced from fighting Daash in Syria and are true guerrilla fighters from their time in Turkey. They have more experience and training than we do.”

KRG president Massoud Barzani came to Maxmur on August 13 to publicly acknowledge the contribution of the PKK fighters.


The USA and other Western States considers the PKK a terror organization and therefore will not “officially work with them.”  So what the hell, work with them unofficially if you want.  I don't care much about your motive at the moment just help the PKK do what the world should be doing.


CDN writes in this vein:



Iraqi terror expert Nasser Kataw said: “There has been a re-drawing of battlefield alliances as people who were once enemies have joined together to try and defeat the scourge that is the Islamic State.”

Well, they should anyway...can't say that I agree that they have. 

Turkey which has long waged a campaign of repression aimed at the PKK and the Kurds in general has negotiated with the PKK recently, though lately their have been setbacks.  However as Links Journal explains:



In July 2013, for the first time in modern Kurdish history, tentative steps were taken to convene a Kurdish National Congress. An organizing committee made up of representatives from all four parts of historic Kurdistan met in Erbil and projected a three-day planning conference for late August with 500-600 delegates. But the project foundered on the political differences between the major forces.


In July this year PKK leader Abdullah Öcalan, held in a Turkish prison since 1999, called for the urgent convocation of a national congress in view of the threat posed by the IS, particularly in Rojava.


And in August, in an atmosphere dominated by the terrible events unfolding in Shengal, 400 Kurdish NGOs in Turkey also issued a call for a Kurdish National Congress that would be able to effectively organize the Kurdish people to deal with the tremendous challenges they face.


Writes the Daily News in Turkey:



 Peoples’ Democratic Party (HDP) Co-Chair Selahattin Demirtaş has said Turkey should consider sending arms to the outlawed Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) in its fight against the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIL).



“The PKK is fighting [against ISIL]. Turkey should consider what to do if the PKK asks for arms. Why not [send arms] when we consider the current peace process? It might sound strange, but why not send arms to the PKK if peace comes and the PKK stops using arms against Turkey and fights against ISIL?” said Demirtaş. 



He also touched on the progress of the peace process, saying President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan would "continue to monitor it."



“Erdoğan wants to have control over the issue. I think he sees himself as being responsible for the issue. So far, there is no time frame written on the table regarding the issue, but they say they want to work with haste,” said Demirtaş.



The HDP co-head said several laws will be enacted by Parliament in October or November concerning the peace process, adding that government officials made clear they do not want to delay their work, including on reforms regarding freedom of speech. He said the government could work on plans for the return of PKK militants to Turkey, rather than an amnesty, in the coming months. 



Demirtaş also said his party would support an independent Kurdish state in Iraq if it was announced. “We also want Turkey to be the first state to recognize such a state,” he added.


In a region where almost everyone oppresses women the Kurds and the KPP are different and that difference is telling.    In the YPG-YPJ (People’s Defense Units-Women’s Defense Units — the military arm of Rojava, the Kurdish liberated area in northern Syria) women make up around 30% of its forces. A similar situation exists with the PKK. Recently a leader of the organization said in an interview that a third of their fighters are women.



A recent report carried by the Firat News Agency, “YPJ fighters demolishing taboos," makes clear the appeal of the liberation armed forces for women in a very patriarchal society.

Women have played a key role in the defense of Kobanê [Ayn Al-Arab] after the revolution, and have created a revolutionary transformation in social attitudes. YPJ (Women's Protection Units) fighters in the forefront of the defense of Kobanê are inflicting heavy blows on ISIS gangs and also demolishing taboos based on male domination …


Destan explained that before she joined the ranks of the YPG two years ago: “my life was between four walls. I had no social or economic life” …


Destan replied to our question as to what had changed after she had joined the YPG-YPJ, saying: “I never used to believe a woman could be the equal of a man before. For instance, in our family the man was always deemed the dominant one and I always considered that normal and legitimate. Here there is a genuine understanding of equality and freedom. I understood in the ranks of the YPJ that male domination was not a normal part of life but was, on the contrary, against the natural order. This created a great feeling of freedom in me.” …


A woman fighter named Roza, who joined the ranks of the YPJ six months ago, sums up the last two months of women's resistance thus: “The most important gain of this conflict has been, in my opinion, the breaking of feudal value judgments in Kobanê. In the last month women have been fighting on the frontline. It may be said that women have inflicted the most crushing blows on the ISIS gangs. Many women have died after putting up heroic resistance. It is now up to us to carry on the struggle in the path of all those who have fallen, first and foremost the women.”

Remarkable?  It shouldn't be, but it is. 

Links Journal concludes:


The Kurds have every right to acquire the weapons they need to defend themselves, even from the US. But the historical record makes it absolutely clear that Washington is no friend of the Kurdish people and any confusion on this score is only going to lead to a lot of grief.


Two key conditions for defeating the IS would seem to be: first, the creation of a genuinely democratic, non-sectarian Iraq which -- among other things -- would address the grievances of the Sunni population and undercut its support for the IS; second, NATO member Turkey must stop supporting the IS gangs and reach a genuine “internal peace” with its own Kurdish population.

Obviously the answer to the mess America and the West has created does not lie in the USA or in NATO...or with the governments of the Gulf States, Saudi Arabia, Iraq, etc.  It lies with the people of the region, with the multitude.

Saying that does not mean that it wouldn't be nice for Obama to quit wrinkling his brow, babbling about air strikes and boots on the ground, about coalitions, and Congress.  Dude, just approve sending arms to the PKK, privately, publicly, whatever, and who cares.  Just do it.  Maybe for one brief, strange moment in time, USA weaponry could be put in the hands of some good people, fighting a good fight, and for a good reason.

This seems unlikely for the reasons expressed below in the article  from CounterPunch.  Global Capital doesn't really want to see what Kevin Carson describes as the



..."democratic confederalism — also influenced by horizontalist struggles like Mexico’s EZLN — as an alternative to both Western corporate capitalism and the Soviet command economy...

Global Capital is not excited about this type of thing appearing in the region as an obvious alternative to itself or USA hegemony.  Oooooh, that sort of idea infesting the heads of the multitude is not at all what the Global Bosses have in mind, not at all.

Still, maybe, those Bosses will "goof up" in the face of their fear of ISIS and do the right thing for whatever reason.  After all, sometimes the world is a strange place and some times the best laid plans of the Global Rats can go astray....


Stay tuned...


Keep your fingers crossed...


Try and figure out what we might be able to do to make something good happen as a result of something awful. 





Obama Wants to Defeat ISIS–But Not That Badly

by KEVIN CARSON

The Obama administration recently announced a policy of limited intervention in Iraq, using drone strikes to stave off conquest of Kurdish autonomous areas by ISIS. The main US ally on the ground is Massoud Barzani’s Kurdistan Regional Government, and US support against ISIS is limited to Kurdish areas inside Iraq.
Barzani’s main competitor for the loyalty of the Kurdish people is Abdullah Ocalan, leader of the Kurdish Workers’ Party (PKK), which is active in all four nations with substantial Kurdish minorities.
While leading the originally Marxist-Leninist PKK from inside a Turkish prison, Ocalan studied the work of anarchist Murray Bookchin and adopted a form of his “libertarian municipalist” philosophy (which he renamed “democratic confederalism”). Bookchin’s philosophy came to Ocalan’s attention as part of a larger wave of interest in libertarian socialist thought among Kurdish nationalists after the fall of the USSR. Ocalan saw democratic confederalism — also influenced by horizontalist struggles like Mexico’s EZLN — as an alternative to both Western corporate capitalism and the Soviet command economy.
Democratic confederalism became the basis for the Group of Communities in Kurdistan, a PKK attempt at territorial administration in Kurdish areas.  It adheres closely to Bookchin’s model of federated direct democracies on the model of the Paris Commune, the soviets that emerged in Russia after the February Revolution, and local anarchist bodies in the Spanish Revolution. The economy is governed by a mixture of worker self-management and participatory planning. Women figure prominently in its municipalities and militia units, and have fought valiantly — for understandable reasons — against ISIS.
PKK is still listed as a terrorist organization because of its violent insurrection against the Turkish government, although it has maintained a truce with Turkey for the past year and gained significant regional autonomy for Kurdish areas in eastern Turkey. Since the truce the PKK moved the bulk of its fighting forces into Iraqi Kurdistan this April.
Supporting the PKK would arguably be far more effective if Obama really wants to stop ISIS penetration of Iraqi Kurdistan, especially given the party’s peace with Turkey and de facto independence of Kurdish areas in northeastern Syria. The PKK and allied militia in Syria have been more successful militarily against ISIS forces than the Western-backed Free Syrian army. PKK defended the Yazidi areas of Iraqi Kurdistan and relocated endangered civilians, when Barzani’s Peshmerga forces melted away. PKK fighters from Turkey have prevented the fall of Kobane in Syrian Kurdistan, which sits across lines of communication between ISIS areas in Syria and Iraq. Ocalan and the PKK, unlike Barzani, have popular support throughout Kurdistan — not just the Iraqi part.
But that’s unlikely to happen. The one thing worse than an ISIS victory, from the American state’s perspective, would be the demonstration effect of an alternative to both corporate capitalism and state socialism, based on decentralism, direct democracy and self-management.
Kurdistan has much in common with postwar Korea. In the power vacuum left by the retreat of Japanese forces from the Korean peninsula, as William Gillis writes (“Mass Graves,” reproduced at Austro-Athenian Empire, May 25, 2008), “something amazing happened. The Korean Anarchists, long the champions of the resistance struggle, came out of the woodwork and formed a nationwide federation of village and workers councils to oversee a massive project of land reform.” Soviet occupation authorities in the north quickly put a stop to this, liquidating the anarchist project and installing the Kim regime. American forces were considerably slower to arrive, giving southern Korea a respite of peace and freedom. When they did arrive, though, American military commanders “had no protocol for dealing with regional federations and anarchist communes.” Accordingly they restored land to the dispossessed aristocracy and helped the landlords set up a military government. With the start of the Korean War the military regime’s murder of anarchists and other leftists, already underway, kicked into high gear. At least 100,000 suspected anarchists, socialists and communists or sympathizers were buried in mass graves.
The American state would rather ISIS not win. But as with the farmers in Orwell’s Animal Farm, the men have one interest in common with the pigs that trumps all others: they don’t want the “animals” — ordinary people — to rule themselves.
Kevin Carson is a senior fellow of the Center for a Stateless Society (c4ss.org) and holds the Center’s Karl Hess Chair in Social Theory.